What is the Best Roasting Pan?

There is nothing better than seeing a big fat turkey sitting in heavy-duty roasting pan to make your mouth water. However when it comes to buying the best roasting pan it can often become a challenge especially when cookware companies are constantly coming out with new and improved roasting pans for chicken, turkey, and vegetables which can leave you scratching your head as to which is the best.

The best roasting pans can be found in a multitude of different materials ranging from aluminum to plain stainless steel, enamel-coated steel, and even tri-ply construction of stainless steel sandwiching a core of aluminum. Typically roaster pans range from 10 inches to 16 inches in length and many of the best come with a roasting rack.

In my search for the best roasting pan I have turned up eight contenders that I have determined are going to be some of the best performers when it comes to roasting the perfect chicken, turkey or even vegetables each and every time.

Choosing The Best Roasting Pan, Which Brand?

When it comes to choosing a new roasting pan there are a few brands that really standout and make some of the best, some come with roasting racks while others come with lids. It really boils down to personal preference as to which you prefer and if you really need a roasting pan with a lid?

Some of the more well-known kitchen cookware manufacturers such as Cuisinart, All-Clad, Calphalon, and KitchenAid make some so excellent roaster pans but tend to also come with a high price tag. If you are choosing the best roasting pan for the money try opting for a lesser known brand, at the end of the day it will be black and burnt after a few uses so it won’t really matter which brand you purchased.

What Are The Best Roasting Pans For Chicken, Turkey And Vegetables?

Not all roasting pans are the same; some are geared towards cooking chicken and turkey while others are the best for vegetables.

If roasting chicken is your goal roasting tray with a rack is going to be your best bet, at least 16 inches in length should be fine. You can also use a cast iron skillet to cook a great tasting chicken if you don’t have a roaster pan.

For turkey the same really applies, just make sure you get a roasting tray that is big enough for your turkey to fit in with a few inches of room around the sides.

For roasting potatoes or vegetables a basic flat roasting pan or tray is going to be the best option, there is no need to use any sort of rack inside the tray.

What To Look For When Buying The Best Roasting Pan?

Depending on what you plan on roasting making sure you have the right roaster pan for the job is essential, let’s take a closer look to make sure you pick out the right one.

The Size

When it comes to roasting pans size does matter! If you are roasting meat it should fit into the pan comfortably and not touching the sides, leaving enough room around the sides of your food will allow for air circulation helping to turn the underside of your roast brown. Also try not to get a pan that is oversized or too big, as this can cause the meat juices to burn because of the larger surface area. It’s all about finding the right balance of size with what you will be placing in the roasting pan.

What about the Depth?

Making sure you buy a roasting pan that is the right depth is crucial. A roaster pan that is too high will cause the air to quickly rise which in-turn will make you food cook unevenly or through thoroughly. The best size roasting pan is between 3 to 4 inches in height this is perfect for roasting meat and this size is perfect for potatoes and vegetables as well.

Shape Does Matter

Generally a rectangular roasting pan ids going to be the best but make sure you buy one that has round corners. The rounded corners help when you make and whisk gravy or sauce directly in the roaster tray and rounded corners also make it a lot easier when it comes to cleaning.

roasting pan reviews

Best Roasting Pan Reviews Three of my Favorites

Still not sure which roasting pan to buy? Below I have picked two of my top picks to help you decide.

Cuisinart 16-Inch MultiClad Pro Stainless Rectangular Roaster with Rack

When choosing the best roasting pan it doesn’t get much better than the Cuisinart. This MultiClad stainless steel roasting pan heats evenly and has no hot spots thanks to the internal layer of aluminum which makes the heat conduction superb.

It is just the right size at 16 inches making it perfect for Thanksgiving cooking and any other celebration. With this roasting pan you’ll have no problem fitting your 22-pound turkey inside and the included roasting pan rack holds the bird firmly and allows for the juices to drain whiles creating the perfect heat circulation.

This roaster pan has durable riveted stainless steel handles that make it much easier to place inside the oven as well as remove.

Cuisinart 16-Inch MultiClad Pro Stainless Rectangular Roaster with Rack


Calphalon Contemporary Stainless Roaster with V Rack

Another of my favorites is the Calphalon Stainless Roaster that comes with a great V Rack for cooking meats to perfection and if you are a fan of slow cooking meats you need to try using this rack!

The roaster pan is made from tri-ply aluminum, which is the best material for even heat conductively after copper. The pan features low sides that allow for even air circulation as well as letting the moisture evaporate quickly.

You will have no problem, placing this pan in the oven, stovetop and it is broiler safe. When stove cooking the handles have been cleverly designed to stay cool!

Calphalon Contemporary Stainless Roaster with V Rack


Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: